legislation and policy
line







spacer image

Report on the NSW Government's Implementation of the Recommendations of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody


2.1 Arrest

    Recommendation Number 87
    Police adherence to principle of arrest as a sanction of last resort

That:
    (a) All Police Services should adopt and apply the principle of arrest being the sanction of last resort in dealing with offenders;
    (b) Police administrators should train and instruct police officers accordingly and should closely check that this principle is carried out in practice;
    (c) Administrators of Police Services should take a more active role in ensuring police compliance with directives, guidelines and rules aimed at reducing unnecessary custodies and should review practices and procedures relevant to the use of arrest or process by summons and in particular should take account of the following matters:
      (i) all possible steps should be taken to ensure that allowances paid to police officers do not operate as an incentive to increase the number of arrests;
      (ii) a statistical data base should be established for monitoring the use of summons and arrest procedures on a Statewide basis noting the utilisation of such procedures, in particular divisions and stations;
      (iii) the role of supervisors should be examined and, where necessary, strengthened to provide for the overseeing of the appropriateness of arrest practices by police officers;
      (iv) efficiency and promotion criteria should be reviewed to ensure that advantage does not accrue to individuals or to police stations as a result of the frequency of making charges or arrests; and
      (v) procedures should be reviewed to ensure that work processes (particularly relating to paper work) are not encouraging arrest rather than the adoption of other options such as proceeding by summons or caution; and
    (d) Governments, in conjunction with Police Services, should consider the question of whether procedures for formal caution should be established in respect of certain types of offences rather than proceeding by way of prosecution.

Government’s original position: Supported
Revised government position: Supported
Agencies responsible for implementation: NSW Police Service

Implementation report
The NSW Police Service Handbook, Aboriginal Policy Statement and Strategic Plan, Custody Managers Key Result Area and all relevant training programs stress the principle of arrest as a last resort and the use of Court Attendance Notices (CAN), summons and cautions where appropriate.

Overnight custodies in police cells have almost been eliminated with the involvement of the Department of Corrective Services in the transportation and detention of police and court prisoners at a large number of centres across the State.

In April 1998, the Young Offenders Act (1997) came into effect. This Act provides police with a broad range of non charge related options for dealing with a wide range of offences committed by young people. The Service is monitoring use of the Act by operational police. Since December 1999, a new data base has been in place and contains a wider range of statistics, including summonses.
The Service is focussed on driving down crime. Whilst part of this focus is on solving crime and putting those responsible before the courts, there is an equal emphasis on crime prevention. The need for police in Local Area Commands to demonstrate an impact on crime levels does not detract from the requirement for appropriate procedures, and alternatives to arrest to be applied in appropriate circumstances. The measure of efficiency is the net reduction in criminal activity in an area, not the number of arrests made.

Arrest statistics are produced monthly and annually and are made available to the public through reports prepared by the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research.

Implementation status
Fully Implemented
Future reporting in Part A





| Previous Page | Back to LAP | Top of Page |

Copyright & Disclaimer | Webmaster
spacer image
The information contained on this page is not legal advice. If you have a legal problem you should talk to a lawyer before making a decision about what to do. The information on this page is written for people resident in , or affected by, the laws of New South Wales, Australia only.
most recently updated 20 August 1999