PrivacyCopyright and Disclaimer SitemapFeedbackHelpSearch
Home
About Us
Recent News
Current Projects
Publications - Active
Digest
Contribute to Law Reform
Law Reform Links
Contact Us
Where am I now? Lawlink > Law Reform Commission > Publications > Report 73 (1994) - Unilateral Severance of a Joint Tenancy

Report 73 (1994) - Unilateral Severance of a Joint Tenancy


Table of Contents

Terms of reference

Participants

Executive summary

Summary of recommendations

1. INTRODUCTION

BACKGROUND TO THE REFERENCE

CONSULTATION

ORGANISATION OF THIS REPORT

2. BACKGROUND

JOINT TENANCY

What is a joint tenancy?


    The right of survivorship

    The four unities


Joint tenancy distinguished from a tenancy in common

Development of joint tenancy


    Position at common law

    Statutory position

    Torrens Title land


HOW POPULAR ARE JOINT TENANCIES?

SEVERANCE OF A JOINT TENANCY

WHY SEVER A JOINT TENANCY?

3. EXISTING METHODS OF UNILATERAL SEVERANCE

INTRODUCTION

SEVERANCE BY ALIENATION

Alienation of real property


    Old System land

    Torrens Title land


Alienation of personal property

SEVERANCE BY CONVERSION

Conveyance to a trustee


    Real property

    Personal property


Direct conveyance to self

SEVERANCE BY DECLARATION OF TRUST

SEVERANCE BY COURT ORDER

Application for sale or partition

Alteration of property interests under the Family Law Act

SEVERANCE BY UNILATERAL DECLARATION

Real property

Personal property

4. SHORTCOMINGS OF THE EXISTING MODES OF EFFECTING UNILATERAL SEVERANCE

ISSUES PERTAINING TO SEVERANCE OF JOINT TENANCY IN ITEMS OF REAL PROPERTY

Transferring interest to trustee to hold on trust

Declaration of trust

Transferring interest to oneself


    Old System land

Alienation

Application for sale or partition

Application under section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975

ISSUES PERTAINING TO SEVERANCE OF JOINT TENANCY IN ITEMS OF PERSONAL PROPERTY

Problems of severance unique to personal property


    Severance of joint tenancies in choses in action

    Identifying the nature of the co-ownership of certain choses in possession


5. WHY SHOULD UNILATERAL SEVERANCE BE SIMPLIFIED?

INTRODUCTION

SEVERANCE AS A PRESENT RIGHT OF CO-OWNERS

JOINT TENANCY AS A MECHANISM OF PROPERTY DISTRIBUTION ON DEATH

WHY IS THE PRESENT LAW UNSATISFACTORY?

WHY NOT SIMPLY ABOLISH JOINT TENANCIES?

CALLS FOR REFORM

RESPONDING TO THE CRITICS

CONCLUSION

6. REFORM IN OTHER JURISDICTIONS

INTRODUCTION

OTHER AUSTRALIAN STATES

Tasmania

Queensland

OVERSEAS JURISDICTIONS

England

Ireland

7. RECOMMENDATION: UNILATERAL SEVERANCE BY REGISTRATION OF A DECLARATION OF SEVERANCE

OPTIONS FOR REFORM

SEVERANCE BY NOTICE

Reasons for rejecting severance by notice


    Severance by notice produces greater uncertainty

    Severancy by notice introduces a greater chance of fraud and/or duress


REGISTERED DECLARATION OF SEVERANCE

CONDITIONAL SEVERANCE ON LODGMENT OF DECLARATION

RECOMMENDATION

8. FEATURES OF THE SYSTEM OF SEVERANCE BY REGISTRATION OF DECLARATION

SHOULD NOTICE TO THE OTHER JOINT TENANTS BE REQUIRED BEFORE SEVERANCE CAN TAKE PLACE?

SHOULD NOTICE TO THE OTHER JOINT TENANTS BE REQUIRED AT ALL?

CERTIFICATE OF TITLE

EFFECT OF THE SEVERANCE

SHOULD THIS METHOD BE THE EXCLUSIVE MEANS OF EFFECTING UNILATERAL SEVERANCE?

SHOULD NOTICE FOLLOWING SEVERANCE BE A REQUIREMENT FOR ALL MODES OF UNILATERAL SEVERANCE?

FORM AND CONTENT OF THE DECLARATION

Content of prescribed RP form “Declaration of severance”

Additional formalities

POSITION OF JUDGMENT CREDITORS, MORTGAGEES AND CHARGEES

Mortgage


    Old System land

    Torrens Title land


Judgment creditor

WHO MAY SEVER UNILATERALLY BY DECLARATION?

EXCEPTIONS TO THE GENERAL RULE

Old System land

Persons holding property as joint tenant by virtue of their office

PERSONAL PROPERTY

CAVEATS

ENLARGEMENT OF JURISDICTION IN PARTITION AND SALE

STAMP DUTY

ISSUES OF LEGAL PRACTICE

SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY



Previous Page | Back to Lawlink Home | Top of Page
  Last updated 28 May 2001   Crown Copyright 2002 ©  
Hosted by
Lawlink NSW