| Case | Offence | Plea | Sentence | Appeal | Record | Facts |
Binge
(35)
NSW CCA
6.4.1995 | s.96 | VG | MT 6y
AT 4y | Conviction and sentence AD
(parity) |  | V confronted by three men in his house. Punched and hit with stick. Tied up. Lost consciousness.
Instigator and inflicted the wounds. |
MRB
(17)
NSWCCA
27.4.1998 | s.96
Sched:
Mal wounding
Assault | PG | MT 3y
AT 3y | AD | drug, property and personal offences in Children’s Court | Removed V’s wallet while being fellated by him in public toilet. Stabbed V three times in chest. Problems with controlling anger. |
B
(17)
NSW CCA
18.90.1998 | s.96 | PG | MT 27m
AT 2y
(PSC 1m) | AA
MT 2y
AT 2y | nil | Arranged with co-accused to rob 64y former landlady. Entered house through ruse, secured V and obtained several hundred dollars. Placed cardigan over V’s head and hit her with iron pipe. Principal actor.
Favourable references. Received one third discount for assistance. |
George
Johnson
NSW CCA [243]
30.6.1999 | s.96
s.96 | VG
VG | MT 5y 6m
AT 3y 6m
MT 5y 9m
AT 3y 3m | AD | agg BES
several | Met V in bar and became friendly - Later in evening robbed and assaulted V - Used broken beer bottles to cut V - Severe injuries - Gratuitous brutal violence. |
Pham
(25)
NSW CCA [225]
2.8.1999 | s.96 (in company)
Sched:
3 x GIC
Receiving | PG | MT 3y
AT 2y 6m | AD | unknown | Robbed shop assistant with co-offender - Armed with knife while co-offender armed with loaded pistol - Struck V with handle of knife
Drug problem |
Haines
(26)
NSW CCA [256]
4.7.2001 | s.96 | PG | 4y
NPP 3y | AD | priors; previous custody. | Female - With co-offender robbed taxi driver of $50. Held knife to V’s throat causing laceration. Co-offender wounded V in back. Aboriginal. |
Teoka
(22)
Lloyd
(18)
ADM
(17)
NSW CCA [373]
1.11.2004 | s.96
s.96
s.96 | PG
PG
PG | 10y
NPP 6y
10y 9m
NPP 6y 9m
11y
NPP 7y | AA
(to backdate sentence)
AA
10y
NPP 6y
AA
10y
NPP 6y | Convictions for assault – breached bail
Convictions for rob in company – breached bail
Conviction for robbery – no previous imprisonment | Punched and kicked male victim until unconscious – Serious injuries - ADM took wallet – T instigated assault – ADM instigated robbery
T – remorse – upset at time of offence over breakdown in relationship with de facto – good prospects of rehabilitation
L – remorse – disturbed childhood
ADM – No remorse – more culpable than others |
Nasher
(18)
NSW CCA [238]
28.6.2005 | s 96 | PG | 6y
NPP 3y
(52d PSC taken into account) | AA
4y
NPP 2y | Minor record as juvenile; offences in breach of bail | Attacked acquaintance from school – thought friends were going to rob V – fractured V’s jaw and took $100 – jealous of V’s comfortable financial situation
18% for PG – not all PSC taken into account - eldest of 8 children in dysfunctional family – NESB – sexually abused as a child – good employment record – good prospects of rehabilitation |
Maisey
NSWCCA [347]
11.10.2005 | s 96 | PG | 9y
NPP 5y 9m | AD | Not stated but breached parole | V physically abused A’s sister – A went to V’s flat with a friend to get some shoes he had given his sister – punched V when he opened the door – took V’s wallet – V jumped off balcony and sustained serious injuries with chronic back pain
Remorse – family loyalty |
Collins
(19)
NSWCCA [162]
22.5.2006 | s.96 | VG | 8y
NPP 5y | AA sentence backdated only. Term of sentence remains 8y NPP 5y. | On bond. Dishonesty, assault, AOABH, larceny. | Female - Slashed V’s handbag strap with knife taking $500 – In tandem with V’s estranged husband – Knew V was vulnerable with spinal injury and using crutch.
Background of heroin and prostitution; paranoid personality disorder. |
