| Case | Offences | Plea | Sentence | Appeal | Record | Facts |
Forrest
(25)
Legge
(female)
(33)
NSW CCA
26.3.1997 | s.94 Assault w/i rob
Robbery
Sched:
Assault w/i rob | PG
PG | MT 2y
AT 2y 3m
MT 3y
AT 18m | AD
AD | property offences
property, violence and drug offences | F drove victim in car to bushland - L demanded money from victim with knife - Victim assaulted |
Green
(29)
NSW CCA
29.9.1997 | s.94 Robbery | PG | MT 3y
AT 3y | AA
MT 2y
AT 2y | assault, property, firearm and driving offences | Robbed bank dressed in beanie, sunglasses and gloves.
Significant ,mental illness subsequent to sentence. |
Morgan
(28)
NSW CCA
24.6.1998 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
2 offences | PG | MT 2y 6m
AT 2y 6m | AD | property and other offences | Dragged woman from car in car park and stole handbag - Threatened victim - Waited while victim called for help then left with handbag - Intoxicated |
Perrett
NSW CCA [115]
15.4.1999 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 3y GBB | Crown AD | nil | Robbed pizza delivery man with co-offender - Stood to one side holding cricket bat
Remorse - Repaid all money - Exceptional circumstances |
McKendrick
NSW CCA [87]
16.4.1999 | s.94 Accessory Before the Fact to Robbery | VG | MT 2y
AT 8m | AA
MT 1y 6m
AT 6m | nil significant | Manager of petrol station - Provided information to co-offenders - Co-offenders robbed employee on way to bank
Parity - Long delay |
Fraser
(23)
NSW CCA [212]
19.7.1999 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
Possess cannabis | PG | MT 12m
AT 18m | AA
MT 9m
AT 21m | motor vehicle offences | Robbed pharmacy with co-offender - waited until no customers in shop
Remorse - Unhappy and violent childhood - Left home early - Evidence of rehabilitation - Special circumstances |
Otto
(22)
NSW CCA [190]
19.7.1999 | 1. s.94 Robbery
2. SMV
3. Breach recog
Sched:
7 x Stealing
Dangerous driving
Drive disqualified | PG | 1. MT 4y
AT 2y
2. FT 12m
3. FT 6m
(All concurrent) | AD | lengthy record - driving, dishonesty and drug offences | Stole and drive in car with co-offenders - Car driven up to pedestrian and co-offender reached out and grabbed bag - Victim fell to ground
Remorse - Drug addiction |
Reynolds
NSW CCA [238]
16.8.1999 | 2 x s.94 Robbery | PG | MT 2y
AT 2y | AD | stealing, assault, drug offences, BES - breached recognisance and periodic detention order | Robbed shops on two occasions, struggling with shopkeepers - first victim injured on back and arm - second victim punched in face
Drug addiction |
Morris
(22)
NSW CCA [252]
18.8.1999 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
BES | PG | MT 2y 3m
AT 1y 9m | AD | Lengthy record including AR - breached bail | Threatened victim in telephone booth and snatched wallet.
Drug addiction - Special circumstances |
Toritto
(39)
NSW CCA [288]
15.9.1999 | s.94 Robbery
s.94 Assault w/i Rob
Sched:
4 x offences | PG | Total:
MT 3y
AT 1y | AD | prior convictions - breached parole and bail | Grabbed gold chain from neck of victim from behind - Attempted to snatch bag from second victim - Struggled with victim but unsuccessful - Both victims female
Drug addiction |
Wheeler
(20)
NSW CCA [34]
16.2.2000 | 4 x s.94 Robbery
s.94 Attempt Rob
2 x s.97(1) (Rob in Company)
Sched:
2 x Assault
4 x Theft MV | PG | 2 x s.94:
MT 9y
AT 3y
Other offences:
FT 4y
(concurrent) | AA
2 x s.94:
FT 4y
s.97(1)
MT 6y
AT 2y
Other offences:
FT 4y
(concurrent)
Total:
MT 6y
AT 2y | breached recognisance and parole- AR | Offences committed over 5 month period - Robberies of banks and other financial institutions - On one occasion took customer hostage and threatened to shoot - Threatened to shoot tellers - On two occasions in company with co-offenders |
Sweetman
(36)
NSW CCA [228]
31.5.2000 | s.94 Robbery | PG | MT 12m
AT 18m | AD | prior convictions | Went behind counter in store with hand under shirt - Took money and left
Intoxicated - Remorse - Spontaneous |
Leonard
(33)
NSW CCA [318]
23.10.2000 | s.94 Robbery | VG | MT 3y
AT 12m | AA
4y
NPP 2y | prior convictions | Struggled with 86y female and stole groceries and purse - Most serious case
Aboriginal with alcohol problems - Psychiatric difficulties - Assault in gaol
Special circumstances. |
Lennox
(39)
NSW CCA [449]
27.10.2000 | s.94 Attempt Rob
Sched:
Possess HB imp | PG | MT 4y
AT 12m | AD | appalling criminal record - breached parole - released from custody 4 days earlier | Attempted to steal purse from female who had just withdrawn money from ATM - In struggled victim fell to ground
Drug addiction |
Burke
(35)
NSW CCA [450]
3.11.2000 | s.94 Robbery | VG | 3y 6m
NPP 18m | Crown AD | lengthy record including violence - on parole for murder | Robbed bank of $3,000 - Dressed in sunglasses, cap and stocking over head
Anti-social and schizoid elements in personality |
Binnie
(38)
NSW CCA [483]
22.11.2000 | s.94 Robbery | PG | MT 6y 9m
AT 2y 3m | AA
7y
NPP 4y | lengthy record - breached parole | Robbed post office of $1,000 |
West
(32)
NSW CCA [26]
14.2.2001 | 1. s.94 Robbery
2. Mal inflict GBH | PG | 1. MT 4y 6m
AT 3y
2. FT 4y
(concurrent) | AD | lengthy record | With co-offender punched victim to head - Kicked fallen victim to head and body - Stole beer and keys - Victim suffered fracture to skull
Aboriginal with dysfunctional childhood - Some prospects of rehabilitation |
Symiziris
(31)
NSW CCA [38]
16.2.2001 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
Receiving | PG | FT 2y | AA
2y
NPP 16m | drug, driving and property offences | Robbed video store of $600
Evidence of rehabilitation - Disabilities caused from car accident |
Ward
(34)
NSW CCA [141]
6.4.2001 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 3y 6m
NPP 2y | AD | property, violence and driving offences | Attempted to snatch bag from 74y female - Threatened to kick - Victim fell to ground in struggle
Drug addiction - Some evidence of rehabilitation |
Warman
(32)
NSW CCA [147]
18.4.2001 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
Multiple offences | PG | 7y
NPP 4y | AD | lengthy record - breached parole | Followed owner of service station home after he closed up - Grabbed victim by shirt then stole briefcase with days takings.
Remorse - Personality disorder - Evidence of attempted rehabilitation - Drug addiction |
Jarman
(30)
NSW CCA [178]
11.5.2001 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
BES | PG | MT 3y 6m
AT 2y 6m | AA
6y
NPP 2y 9m | lengthy record - breached bail and parole for robbery | Robbed bank of $1,670 - Told teller he had a gun
Co-operated with police - Genuine attempt to overcome addiction |
Mannering
(39)
NSW CCA [275]
9.7.2001 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 5y
NPP 3y | AA
3y 6m
NPP 2y 3m | lengthy record although no imprisonment | Asked 69y female shop keeper for cigarettes then sprayed victim with capsicum spray - Stole money
Heroin addiction - Remorse - Attempts at rehabilitation - Coping with death of mother |
Rudenko
(24)
NSW CCA [519]
12.12.2001 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
2 x drug offences | PG | 3y 5m
NPP 2y 6m | AD | dishonesty offences - breached bond | Robbed TAB employee of $7,926 in briefcase attached to her arm - Showed victim federal police badge, pushed her away and used pliers to cut chain
Drug addiction |
Andrews
(35)
NSW CCA [18]
1.2.2002 | 1) 2 x s.94 Principal in 2nd degree
2) 4 x s.94 Access After the Fact Rob | PG | 1. 4y 6m
NPP 2y
2. FT 12m
(All concurrent) | AA
1. 3y 6m
NPP 18m | property, violence and driving offences | Female - Driver of vehicle used by de facto and another to commit robberies on retail outlets - Accompanied by children on several occasions
Influenced by co-offender - Good prospects of rehabilitation |
Hoadley
(28)
NSW CCA [39]
15.2.2002 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 2y
NPP 18m | AD | lengthy record | Followed victim after ATM transaction - Knocked victim to ground and took mobile phone
Some prospects of rehabilitation |
Eldridge
(26)
NSW CCA [205]
3.6.2002 | 1. s.94 Robbery
2. AOABH | VG | 1. 6y
NPP 4y 6m
2. FT 9m
(concurrent) | AD | lengthy record | Followed 7m pregnant female from bank and snatched bag - Stole $5,080 - Punched man accompanying victim |
Christian
(43)
NSW CCA [264]
19.6.2002 | 1. s.94 Robbery
2. s.94 Robbery
Sched:
s.94
Demand money w/i to steal | PG | Each:
3y 2m
NPP 2y | Crown AA
1. 4y
NPP 2y | very lengthy record - breached parole | Robbed TAB agency pretending to be armed with gun - 3 days later robbed video store in same circumstances - Schedule offences involved TAB agencies
Aboriginal with drug addiction - Depressive illness responding to treatment |
Ingram
(21)
NSW CCA [398]
27.9.2002 | s.94 Robbery
Sched:
3 x Obtain money by deception
BES | PG | 3y 6m
NPP 18m | AA
3y
NPP 15m
(fresh evidence as to protective custody) | driving, minor drug and shoplifting offences - serving bond and imprisonment | Snatched bag from 75y lady on street - Violently shook bag and caused victim to fall - Spontaneous
Genuine remorse - Drug addiction - Evidence of rehabilitation - Borderline personality disorder - Need for extensive counselling - Fresh evidence as to protective custody status |
Logan
(21)
NSW CCA [185]
24.6.2003 | 1. s.94 Robbery
2. s.94 Steal from Person
3. Mal Damage | PG | 1. 5y 6m
NPP 2y 6m
2. FT 2y 3m
3. FT 12m
Total:
6y
NPP 3y | AD | Prior convictions in NSW and Qld – no gaol – second offence committed on bail | Robbed pedestrian – made threat to stab – Grabbed handbag containing mobile phone and cash from female in car – destroyed mobile phone on apprehension by police.
Aboriginal – Alcohol abuse – Unfortunate background |
Marinos
NSW CCA [136]
30.4.2003 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 2y 3m
NPP 15m | AA
2y 3m
NPP 9m | Minor record | Snatched bag from 56y woman on street.
Drug addiction – Some steps towards rehabilitation |
Eid
(26)
NSW CCA [211]
14.8.2003 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 4y
NPP 3y | AA
4y
NPP 2y 8m | Significant record including armed robbery – on parole | Approached stationary vehicle at lights and forced victim from car – Stole car – Drug debt
Prospects of rehabilitation from long-term drug addiction |
Penalosa-Munoz
(24)
NSW CCA [33]
26.2.2004 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 18m
NPP 1m | Crown AD | Nil | Robbed complainant at ATM – threat to kill if went to police
Colombian with turbulent and violent background – Voluntary confession – Genuine contrition – Prior good character – Excellent prospects of rehabilitation – HIV - delay |
Gibbs
(18)
NSW CCA [399]
30.9.2004 | s.94 Robbery | PG | 3y
NPP 16m | AD | Breached control order for agg robbery | Grabbed bag from victim standing at railway – impulsive – low level of violence
Seriously dysfunctional childhood including violence and disadvantage – Borderline intelligence – Drug and alcohol abuse - Aboriginal |
Muscat
NSW CCA [259]
14.7.2006 | s.94 | PG | 18m
NPP 9m
PD | Crown AD | Not significant | Involved in robbery of shop employee taking money to bank – provided inside information to co-offender – lesser offender
Good character – good prospects of rehabilitation |
Daniels
NSW CCA [154]
12.12.2007 | s.94 | PG | 4y
NPP 2y | AD | Lengthy | Entered university cafeteria, threatened manager and took $2480. |
Kokaua
(21)
NSW CCA [111]
26.5.2008 | s.94 | PG | 3y 6m
NPP 1y 9m | AD | yes | Assaulted victim in park – Put hand in victim’s pocket – Allegedly also took victim’s dog.
Mental health issues - schizophrenia type symptoms- Need for close supervision – Special circumstances. |
Pace
(27)
NSW CCA [233]
30.10.2008 | 2 x s.94
Att s.94 | PG | 3y 1m
NPP 13m | Crown AD | Record – Breached bail and parole | Robbed convenience store using death threats – One month later attempted to rob convenience store with stocking over head – robbed fast food shop - attempted to rob third store but detained by security guards
Admissions to police - Schizophrenic |
