| Case | Offence | Amount | Plea | Record | Result | Appeal | Facts |
Moore
(37)
Wiebe
(35)
NSW CCA
1.8.1992 | Conspiracy to supply
Supply | 798.8g (633g pure - capable of producing 6,000 tablets with street value of $240,000.) | PG
PG | minor
nil | MT 3y 6m
AT 1y 2m
MT 3y
AT 1y | Crown AD
AD | M a member of “Orange People” – Asked to arrange importation - W to be paid $10,000 – W brought in tablets strapped to back.
M – Canadian – Married - Contrition
W – Canadian – Courier - Assistance – Prior good character |
Lao
(52)
NSW CCA [315]
31.10.2003 | Supply | 1016.6g | PG | Nil | 5y
NPP 3y | AD | Courier
Gambling problem – Good character – Strong prospects of rehabilitation |
OPA
(39)
NSW CCA [464]
17.12.2004 | Knowingly take part in supply | 3.1kg | PG | Nil | 8y
NPP 6y | AA
5y 8m
NPP 4y 3m | Found in possession of drugs – involved in extensive operation – took orders, supplied drugs and collected money – underling
Valuable assistance – special protection |
Nassif
(32)
NSW CCA [38]
15.2.2005 | Attempt receive for supply large commercial qty | 3.2452kg | PG | Priors including drug supply | 6y
NPP 3y | AD | Agreed to take delivery of 14,000 tablets from Sukkar (see importation commercial quantity of ecstasy table) |
Thompson
(34)
NSW CCA [340]
29.9.2005 | Supply large commercial quantity
Sched:
Supply tablet
GIC | 1.983kg | PG | Priors including drug supply | 16y
NPP 12y | AA
13y 4m
NPP 10y | Found in possession of drugs
Erroneous consideration of standard non-parole period |
Yildiz
(2006) 160 A Crim R 218 | Supply large commercial quantity | 602g | PG | Nil | 10y
NPP 7y | AD | Arrested during agreement to supply – found in possession of drugs. |
Stankovic
NSW CCA [229]
1.8.2006 | Supply large commercial qty
Sched:
4 offences | 44kg | PG | Nil | 7y 9m
NPP 5y 2m | Crown AA
11y 8m
NPP 8y 9m | Involved in manufacture of MDMA at residential premises – Engaged as labourer in illicit factory – Unsupervised – Claim of duress. |
Nikolic
(45)
NSW CCA [232]
8.8.2007
Co-offender:
STANKOVIC | Knowingly concerned in supply large commercial qty | 44kg | PG | Nil | 9y
NPP 6y | Crown AA
12y 9m
NPP 8y 6m | Involved in manufacture of MDMA at residential premises – Agreed to assist co-offender out of obligation for assistance given to son in Serbia – lesser offender – below mid-range
Remorse |
Knight
(34)
Biuvanua
(34)
NSW CCA [283]
24.9.2007 | Supply
Take part in supply | 961g | PG
PG | Minor
Nil relevant | 10y
NPP 6y
3y 6m
NPP 2y | Crown AA
14y 4m
NPP 10y
Crown AD | K (female) head of drug syndicate employing others – B(husband) assisted in menial tasks |
Sukkar
NSW CCA [298]
10.10.2007 | Supply | 5.9kg | PG |  | 11y 6m
NPP 7y 6m | AD | Offence committed after 1.2.2003
Arrested during transaction. No further facts provided.
Assistance to authorities. |
Lim
Gao
NSW CCA [343]
14.12.2007 | Supply large comm. quantity
Sched:
2 x supply drugs
Supply large commercial qty
Supply comm. qty
Sched:
3 x supply drugs |  | PG
PG | Agg robbery | 8y
NPP 5y
Large Comm
11y
NPP 7y
Total:
12y
NPP 8y | Crown AA
9y 10m
NPP 6y
Crown AD | Offences committed after 1.2.2003
Entered into agreement to supply $5000 worth of tablets (weighing between 1 – 2.5 kg) to undercover police operative – no actual supply. |
Edwards
(23)
NSW CCA [281]
3.12.2008 | Supply large comm. qty (E)
2 x Supply comm. qty (A)
Supply comm. qty (E)
Sched:
3 offences | 1680g
381.3g
301.29g
225g | PG | Nil | 17y
NPP 10y
(concurrent sentences) | AD | Offences committed after 1.2.2003
Supplied over three months – sophisticated operation
True remorse – good prospects of rehabilitation |
Woodgate
(44)
NSW CCA [137]
7.5.2009 | Supply large comm. qty (E)
Sched:
GIC | 67.79g tabs
42.956kg
10.921kg tabs
12.234kg powder | PG |  | 14y
NPP 10y | AD | Offences committed after 1.2.2003
Drugs found in apartment, unfurnished house and storage facility – also found in possession of $31,805, pill press and other equipment – senior trusted figure |
Xue
(37)
NSW CCA [227]
10.9.2009 | Supply large comm. qty | 852.9g | PG | Not significant. | 13y 6m
NPP 10y | AD | Supplied tablets to undercover police operative.
Drug abuse – gambling. |
Wang
NSW CCA [223]
10.9.2009 | Supply large comm. qty
Supply not less trafficable
Assault police officer | 1464.46g | VG | Driving, dishonesty, firearms – summary offences only. | 20y
NPP 15y | AA
16y
NPP 12y | Observed with bag later found to contain 5000 ecstasy tablets – struggled with police officer at scene – got away and later observed with another bag found to contain smaller quantity of ecstasy tablets.
SJ erred in assessment of objective gravity – offence below mid range – paucity of evidence relating to applicant’s role.
Reference to other supply cases. |
Fitzsimon
(32)
NSW CCA [25]
4.3.2010 | Supply large comm. qty
Supply meth
Sched:
2 x supply 56g meth | 1.7kg
54.84g | PG | Significant although older record | 9y 4m
NPP 6y
FT 2y (concurrent) | AD | SNPP 15 years
On four occasions took possession of drugs and provided them to co-offender to drive north to third offender – involved in substantial drug organisation but received small financial rewards only
Reasonable prospects of rehabilitation – suffering mental condition |