Public Defenders
spacer
print  Print page  
Drugs - Cocaine - Possess Prohibited Import - Less than Commercial Quantity


Customs Act 1901 (Cth)
s.233B(1) - import prohibited drug
s.235(2)(d) - maximum penalty - 25y
Commercial quantity – 2kg
(repealed 6.12.2005)

Criminal Code (Cth)
s.307.6 – possess marketable quantity unlawful import
s.307.9 – possess marketable quantity reasonably suspected unlawful import
Maximum penalty – 25y
Commercial quantity –2kg
Marketable quantity – 2g


CaseOffenceAmountPleaRecordResultFacts
Ferrer-Esis
(1991) 55 A Crim R 231
Possess1819.8g (pure)PGnil6y
NPP 3y 6m
Crown AA
9y
NPP 5y
Cocaine as serious as heroin - Courier - Venezuelan.
Laurentiu




Becheru

(1992) 63 A Crim R 402
Possess




Possess
32g of original importation of 1.589 kgPG




VG
Prior drug matters, offence committed on bailEffective sentence:
10y 6m
NPP 7y 6m


7y
NPP 4y 6m
ADCo-offender imported cocaine. Apprehended at airport and controlled delivery made to L and B. B regarded as ‘back up muscle’. L a few rungs down from principal.
Gonzalez
(23)
NSW CCA 2.9.1993
Possess1002g
(77.5% purity)
PGnil7y
NPP 4y 6m
ADControlled delivery to appellant arranged with importer. Sought to mislead the police. Co-offender greater involvement, but greater assistance.
Smith
NSW CCA 30.9.1994
Possess711g (pure)PG7y
NPP 4y 6m
ADDrugs mailed to appellant so treated as a courier.
De Hesselle
NSW CCA
29.8.1997
Possess1.93kg (pure)VGnil8y
NPP 5y
ADNot the importer. Apprehended after sale to another person.
Stafrace
(31)
(1997) 96 A Crim R 452
2 x Possess726g (pure)
937g (pure)
PGnil12y
NPP 9y
10y
NPP 6y
Individually in possession of one box of cocaine and jointly in possession of second box. Partly for own use, partly for commercial operation - knew joint possessor involved in supply and assisting him by keeping cocaine. More than mere courier. Cocaine addiction.
Selim
NSW CCA
19.5.1998
Attempt possess221g (pure)PG3y
18m NPP
ADCocaine imported by female. Controlled delivery to A. A’s role was to deliver drug and would receive some of the cocaine as payment.
26 years old at sentence. Provided assistance. Good rehabilitation in gaol. Father dying of cancer.
Watson
(29)
NSW CCA
18.9.1998
Attempt possess1.43kg (pure)PGminor and unrelated - treated as first offender9y
6y NPP
ADIntended to take delivery from courier. Controlled delivery undertaken and A caught. Claimed he was to deliver drugs to Lebanese, and his reward was one ounce. Dealt with as “collector” - same as courier. Objective gravity very high.
Recreational user.
Adorjany
NSW CCA [37]
5.3.1999
PossessSee factsPGnil10y
6y 3m NPP
ADCourier intercepted by police on arrival from Colombia with cocaine in luggage. Courier met appellant in controlled delivery. Appellant took cocaine (substitute) and paid courier. 2.796kg (pure) imported
Pulido
NSW CCA [438]
2.12.1999
Possess296.9g (pure)PG6y 6m
NPP 4y 6m
ADReceived package from Colombia.
Sando
NSW CCA [301]
11.8.2000
Attempt possess156g (pure)PG6y
NPP 3y
ADCocaine imported by courier - controlled delivery made to appellant. Addict who took opportunity to be involved in drug delivery - marginally more culpable than a courier.
Assistance discount.
Taru
(24)
NSW CCA [391]
13.9.2002
Attempt possess101.8g (pure)PGminor4y 9m
NPP 3y
ADArranged for delivery of package to studio - Arrested after picking up package - Courier
Good subjective evidence - Remorse
Ntsele
NSW CCA [111]
30.4.2003
Attempt possess heroin
Possess cocaine
311.9g (pure)

1,307g (pure)
PG6y
NPP 3y 2m
(concurrent)
Crown AA
6y
NPP 4y
8y
NPP 4y
(concurrent)
Took possession of heroin from co-offender - Cocaine found in police search of premises - Higher level of involvement than co-offender
Delay in instituting appeal - Discount for assistance too high - Error to make sentences identical and concurrent
Maloney
NSW CCA [250]
28.7.2004
Attempt obtain possessionTrafficable amountVGNil8y
NPP 5y
ADCocaine hidden in packages sent from Caribbean



POST REPEAL s.16G

CaseOffenceAmountPleaRecordSentenceAppealFacts
Haidar
(28)
NSW CCA [350]
15.10.2004
Attempt possess391.7g (pure)PGNil7y
NPP 4y 6m
ADCocaine secreted in computer sent from Brazil – Controlled delivery – Slightly above courier
Drug addiction at time of offence
Okeke
NSW CCA [444]
16.12.2005
2 x Attempt possess190.3g (pure)
195.8g (pure)
PGNil – dishonest dealings with Immigration9y
NPP 6y
ADNigerian national – arranged for pick up of two parcels containing cocaine mailed from Brazil – controlled delivery – role of “some substance”
SC
(27)
NSW CCA [29]
21.2.2008
Attempt possess183.9g (pure)PGNil3y 6m
NPP 2y
Crown ADCocaine secreted in parcels – took delivery on behalf of another person – aware drugs involved but probably not aware of weight – to be paid $3,000
Prior good character – drug user – good prospects of rehabilitation – assistance
Appeal dismissed in exercise of discretion of court
Milich
NSW CCA [148]
26.6.2008
Attempt possess296.9g (pure)VGNil10y
NPP 6y
AA
8y
NPP 4y 9m
Female – took delivery of parcels on behalf of Nigerian man – Used false identity and rented flat



CRIMINAL CODE

CaseOffenceAmountPleaRecordSentenceAppealFacts
Navasardian
(31)

Petrosyan
(28)

NSW CCA [108]
17.4.2009
Possess


Aid and abet importation
1.753kgPG


PG
Minor


Minor
8y 4m
NPP 5y 3m

7y 9m
NPP 4y 10m
AA
6y 6m
NPP 4y

6y
NPP 3y 8m
Cocaine imported in brake drum – N to take delivery of imported package – low in hierarchy – P ennobled in facilitating delivery of package
40% discount for guilty plea and assistance – married with children – Armenian – reasonable prospects of rehbailtation




Previous Page | Back to Lawlink Home | Top of Page
  Last updated 15 September 2009   Crown Copyright ©  
Hosted by agd logo
Lawlink NSW