Public Defenders
spacer
print  Print page  
+Drugs - Cannabis - Cultivate Large Commercial Quantity

This table is intended to be used as a guide only. Individual cases should be read if they are to be relied upon.


· s.23(2(a) Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW) - cultivate commercial quantity
· s.33(3)(b) Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 (NSW) - maximum penalty 20y
· Large commercial quantity - 1000 plants


CaseOffenceAmountPleaPriorsSentenceAppealFacts
Kasadelis


Tsagaris


Pelle
NSW CCA
5.9.1994
Cultivate


Cultivate


Cultivate
PG


PG


PG
nil relevant


supply and cultivate

nil
MT 5y
AT 1y 8m

MT 3y 6m
AT 1y 2m

MT 3y
AT 1y
AD


AD


AD
Cultivation on remote property near Bourke. K was entrepreneur. T and p workers only, T involved longer than P.
K motivated by difficult financial position. Suffered from heart condition making imprisonment more onerous. Genuinely contrite.
P: severely handicapped child, genuinely contrite, difficult financial position.
Pellizzeri
NSW CCA
15.11.1991
Cultivate9665 plantsPGNilMT 3y
AT 1y
(JIRS summary)
Crown appeal dismissedPolice raided a plantation consisting of 9,665 cannabis plants on which the respondent was the caretaker and worker (not a principal person) and in possession of a gun.
Aged 45. Italian immigrant. Psychiatric report referred to a "disturbed domestic background".
Overall
NSW CCA
29.11.1996
Knowingly take part in cultivation4,646 plantsPGMT 1y
AT 1y
ADSerious horticultural endeavour. Played important but not primary role in offence. Purchased equipment and visited workers daily. Pressured into offence when under financial stress.
Very strong subjective case. Valuable assistance to authorities.
Catanzariti

Piromalli

Trajkov

NSW CCA
31.10.1997
Cultivate3169 plantsPGof no significanceMT 6y
AT 2y
AA
MT 3y
AT 1y
Each played important role over three month period.
Barbara
NSW CCA
24.2.1997
Cultivate4237 plantsPGnil2y 6m PDCrown AD
(inadequate but dismissed because of ill health)
4,237 plants growing in the roof cavity of the respondent's flower plantation. Extensively developed cultivation materials.
Aged 63. Driven by financial failure. Strong family support. Severe angina and evidence of marked deterioration since sentence.
Oygur
NSW CCA
31.10.1997
Cultivate

Sched:
3 x possession
1239 plantsPGproperty, drugs. No previous custody.MT 2y 18 days
AT 9m 12 days
(+ 2m PSC)
ADPolice videotaped the applicant and another at a property tending 1,239 cannabis plants.
Aged 34.
Giacobello
(46)
NSW CCA [473]
26.11.2001
Cultivatemore than 2000 plantsPGprior record including trafficking cannabis4y
NPP 3y
ADAdmitted taking part as cultivator for financial gain.
Skorin
(28-9)
NSW CCA [276]
11.8.2005

Co-offender:
MANGANO
Knowingly take part in cultivation6,765 plantsPGNil2y 2m
NPP 1y
Crown AA
4y 6m
NPP 2y 9m
Involved in cultivation on rural property – intermediate level – Organised and supplied materials and recruited one worker – Commercial gain
Assistance
Nguyen
(22)
[2005] NSW CCA, 448
8.2.2006
Knowingly take part in cultivateOver 30,000 plantsPGNil9y
NPP 5y
AA
5y 6m
NPP 3y
Recruited to work on plantation for four months
Parity
Mangano
NSW CCA [35]
24.2.2006

Co-offender:
SKORIN
Knowingly take part in cultivation

Sched:
Knowingly take part in cultivation
Nearly 10,000 plants

Over 6.000 plants
PGNil2y
NPP 14m
PD
Crown AA
4y 5m
NPP 2y 5m
Involved in two plantation over 6 months – Assistant / labourer – to be paid $100,000
Financial difficulty – good character - assistance
Mammone
(73)
NSW CCA [138]
24.4.2006

Co-offender:
SKORIN
VALENSISE
Knowingly take part in cultivationOver 6000 plantsPGShoot with intent. On parole.5y 2m 12d
NPP 2y 6m
Crown AA
5y 8m
NPP 3y 6m
Involved in two plantations – cleared land, visited and inspected crops, recruited workers.
Elderly – ill health – special circumstances.
Nguyen
(47)
NSW CCA [253]
25.8.2006

Co-offender:
NGUYEN
CANNISTRA
NGUYEN
Cultivate30,051 plantsVGSupply drugs12y
NPP 9y
AA
9y
NPP 6y 9m
Labourer on large plantation – to earn $100,000.
Parity
Valensise
NSW CCA [315]
10.10.2006

Co-Offender:
SKORIN
MAMMONE
Knowingly take part in cultivation

Sched:
Supply cannabis
Supply ecstasy
Supply methyl
6,795 plants



978.7g
87.5g
7.18g
PGNil significant30m
NPP 8m 30d
Crown AA
3y 4m
NPP 2y
Involved in two properties in country
Cannistra
(64)


Nguyen
(25)

NSW CCA [389]
4.12.2006

Co-offender:
NGUYEN
NGUYEN
Knowingly take part in cultivation

Sched:
Cultivate lge comm. qty
30,051PG



PG
Minor



Nil
7y 3m
NPP 4y 9m


8y 2m
NPP 5y 2m
Crown AA
9y
NPP 5y 10m

Crown AD
Involved in three crop sites in rural area
C – central figure at property and controlling mind – assistance – ill health
N – female – in relationship with C – paid to recruit and carry out tasks – more than worker – assistance - depression
Gattellari
(20)

McRae
(26)

NSW CCA [5]
22.1.2007
Cultivate2,742PG


PG
Nil


Minor
5y 9m
NPP 3y 2m
ADManaged plantation in remote area after injury to co-offender – extensive indoor cloning operation inside steel shed – soccer field sized outdoor crop
Both of good character
Licastro
(36)
NSW CCA [131]
22.7.2008
Knowingly take part in cultivation3,831 plantsVGRecord including drug use and possession offences8y
NPP 6y
ADPrincipal in sophisticated plantation
Long history of drug abuse
Bui
(46)
NSW CCA [314]
18.12.2008
Cultivate

Sched:
Possess 168g leaf
281 plantsPGNil relevant5y
NPP 3y
ADSophisticated and well organised cultivation – profit only
Vietnamese – gambling problem
Romano, N


Romano, L
NSW CCA [63]
13.3.2009
Knowingly take part in cultivation8000 plantsPG


VG
10y
NPP 6y

8y 11m
NPP 5y
AD


AD
N principal in cultivation. L middle echelon in operation.




Previous Page | Back to Lawlink Home | Top of Page
  Last updated 15 September 2009   Crown Copyright ©  
Hosted by agd logo
Lawlink NSW