Case	Offence	Amount	Plea	Sentence	Appeal	Record	Facts
McGrath (34) NSW CCA 20.4.1993	Supply	26-7g	PG	MT 18m AT 6m	AD	recog, stealing, supply (gaol)	Deemed supply: drugs found on A.
Sabbah (18) NSW CCA 17.12.1993	Supply	10.91g	PG	MT 1y 6m AT 6m	AA MT 1y AT 1y	on recog, supply, possess, GIC, (no gaol)	Drugs found on A and in car by police. Admitted selling capsules for someone else, and had sold 20-25 tablets. Good prospects of rehab.
Decandia (28) NSW CCA 8.7.1994	Supply Sched: 2 x possess	56g	PG	MT 12m AT 12m	AD	includes drugs	Admitted involvement from the start. Supplied drugs four times over several weeks. Did not make a profit. Long history of drug abuse.
Morrissey NSW CCA 15.7.1994	Supply Sched: 5 x minor drug offences	9.7g	PG	MT 2y 3m AT 9m	AD		Deemed supply. Equipment found in home relating to supply. SJ found A “in a commercial sense, involved as a supplier”. Not a drug user.
Sneddon NSW CCA 12.10.1994	Supply Sched: possess cannabis	21.75g	PG	MT 18m AT 6m	AD	extensive	no details
Woodger (39) NSW CCA 21.9.1995	supply	6.95g	VG	MT 2y AT 1y	AA MT 12m AT 6m No evidence of pattern of supply.	BES, stealing, possess	Drug found with $350. Claimed for own use. Invalid pensioner. Drug user.
Smythe NSW CCA 6.9.1996	supply	7.28g	VG	MT 6m AT 9m	AD	nil	Found in house with equipment for supply. Young woman. Good subjectives.
CFR (45) NSW CCA 30.10.1996	2 x supply Sched: Supply amphet	18g (Form 2: 11g)	PG	MT 12m AT 4m	AD	drugs, AR, robbery, dishonesty	Police arranged to purchase 2g amphetamine from A. Amphetamine later found on A and in house with equipment associated with supply. Form 2 offence occurred two months later. Discount for assistance
Brown (38) NSW CCA [349] 25.10.1999	Supply	25.11g	VG	MT 6m AT 12m	AD	no supply convictions	Female found in possession of drug. Equipment associated with supply found at house. Dependent daughter with minimal family support. Suffering hepatitis.
Mason NSW CCA [82] 22.3.2000	Supply	3.1g	PG	MT 3y AT 1y (cumulative to earlier assault sentence)	AA MT 12m AT 6m		Actual supply to undercover agent of 3.1g methylamphetamine. Supply not isolated transaction but part of ongoing business. Small cog in sophisticated dealing operation. Drug addiction.
Davidson NSW CCA [393] 21.6.2000	2 x Supply Sched: Possess cannabis Firearm offence	6.6g	PG	MT 9m AT 18m	AA 3y GBB (irrelevant and prejudicial material before SJ)	no relevant record	Supplied to police operative and discussed further supply. Suffering medical condition.
Atkin NSW CCA [54] 20.2.2001	4 x supply Sched: 3 cannabis off	10.3g (2% pure) 2.5g (15% pure)	PG	2y 6m NPP 12m (concurr to existing sentence)	Crown AD (manifestly inadequate but about to be released)		Found by police in possession of methylamphetamine and equipment used for sale. While on bail sold small amounts of methylamphetamine to police officer on 3 consecutive days. Concurrency means will only serve 40 days
Donnelly NSW CCA [203] 9.5.2001	Supply	10.9g	VG	MT 26m AT 9m (+1m PSC)	AD	prior drug offences - appeal bail at time of offence	Found in possession of drug and equipment for supply.
Brown NSW CCA [367] 12.9.2001	Supply x 2 Sched: 2 x possession	27.5g 22.8g	PG	5y NPP 3y	AA 4y NPP 2y.	drugs, property.	On two occasions police found drugs in vehicle. Aged 42. Addict. Strong subjective features. Rehabilitation. Not previously imprisoned.
Groat (39) NSW CCA [452] 17.10.2001	3 x supply	2.83g 3.2g 30.52g	PG	3y NPP 2y	AA 2y 6m NPP 18m	cultivation small number of plants	Supplied to undercover police officer. Larger amount of drugs found in possession. Erred in treating criminal record as aggravating factor.
Shaw NSW CCA [498] 21.11.2001	Supply	0.41g	VG	30m NPP 22.5m	AA 2y NPP 12m		Small time dealer in amphetamines - Only dealt with in District Court because part of larger indictment at trial - Not isolated incident of dealing but erroneously dealt with as if representative of continuous dealing Medical condition
Maarbani NSW CCA [509] 13.12.2001	Supply Sched: 7 offences	9.5g at 2.5% purity	GP	2y 6m NPP 18m (cumulative to 6m for breach CSO)	AA 2y 6m NPP 14m	consistent pattern of offending	Found in possession of drugs - offences taken into account include cultivation and drive manner dangerous Manifestation of epilepsy subsequent to sentencing justifies reduction in sentence.
Holden (23) NSW CCA [397] 27.9.2002	Supply Sched: 2 x possess cannabis GIC	42.9g methyl 23.5g cannabis 6.8g resin	PG	4y NPP 2y	AA 3y NPP 18m	minor	Found in possession of drugs at premises- Small time supplier - Maintaining drug habit Judge erred in finding supplier to significant degree - Failure to reflect guilty plea
Nastoski NSW CCA [528] 20.12.2002	Supply	14.9g	PG	18m NPP 10m	AD	drugs	Assisted another person in drug supply business - Supplied 100 tablets. Late plea.
Dineen (38) NSW CCA [193] 14.7.2003	6 x Supply Sched: 9 x supply	Various small amounts	PG	6y 6m NPP 4y	AA 5y NPP 3y	Minor convictions for possession	Female - Involved in sale of drugs in busy and thriving business from house
Roby (54) NSW CCA [242] 19.8.2003	2 x Supply Sched: 3 offences	21.32g 19.68g	PG	8y NPP 6y 6m	AA 8y NPP 6y	2nd offence committed on bail – Similar offences	Female - Drugs found in house on first occasion and again three months later – Active drug dealer Mitigating subjective features
Maessen NSW CCA [160] 15.3.2004	3 x Supply Sched: 3 minor offences	.74g 1.11g .48g	PG	2y 9m NPP 1y 9m	AA 18m NPP 1y 1m 4d (immediate release)	Minor – breached bond	Isolated incidents – Could have been dealt with summarily – Objective seriousness of offending very low – Failure to give proper discount for utilitarian aspect of guilty plea
Bradley NSW CCA [88] 6.4.2004	Supply Sched: Supply drug, 3 x possess drug	1g per day over two month period	PG	2y NPP 1y	AD	Not stated	Female – drugs found in home – Admissions to police re supplying amphetamine on regular basis over two month period, selling 1 gram per day on behalf of another person to finance purchase of cannabis for her own use - Earned $2000 to $5000 per week for the person supplying her with drug.
Moss (31) NSW CCA [422] 2.12.2004	Supply	5.7g (21.5%)	VG	16m NPP 1y	AD – by majority	Minor; some drugs;	Found by police in possession of drugs Female – fresh evidence of pregnancy – baby will live with mother for term of custodial sentence – mother to three other children
Payne (34) NSW CCA [84] 5.4.2005	Supply	34.7g (only 17g for supply)	PG	12m NPP 9m (PD) concurrent to existing sentence	Crown AA 20m NPP 12m (PD) cumulative	Assault and drug offence - breached bond	Obtained drug to share with partner – drug addicts – no commercial element
Schumacher (32) NSWCCA [335] 22.9.2005	Supply Sched Drive disq		VG - offer to PG to lesser charge	2y NPP 13m	AD	Nil	Addicted to amphetamines and began supplying to fund personal use and drug debts - not commercial enterprise Delay –offer to plea guilty not expressly taken into account - Two children with co-offender (currently in jail) – positive urine tests while on Griffiths remand
Radisich (36) NSW CCA [52] 3.3.2006	Supply Sched: 4 offences	1.3g	PG	2y 6m NPP 12m	AA 2y NPP 11m 7d (immed release)	Minor	Assisted primary offender in series of transactions Evidence of rehabilitation from drug abuse
Ghossein NSW CCA [108] 5.4.2006	Supply	13.3g	VG	2y NPP 18m	AD	BES	A searched at police station – released upon finding no drugs – police found condom behind station containing drugs - DNA tests revealed condom had been in A’s possession . Drug addiction. Supportive family.
Young NSW CCA [114] 26.4.2007	Supply Breach GBB Sched: Possess M		PG	Drug offence: 3y NPP 18m Total: 3y 6m NPP 2y	AA Only to backdate sentence	Breached bail and bond for deemed supply offence	Supplied small amounts of crystal methylamphetamines to prostitutes over 2 months
Pearman NSW CCA [342] 10.12.2007	Supply	90.5g (250 tablets)	PG	2y NPP 14m	AA 1y 2m NPP 10m		While at girlfriend’s house, C (girlfriend’s brother) telephoned that T would arrive with drugs for delivery to C – A offered to take drugs in his bag – girlfriend drove A in her car to C’s house – intercepted by police who were conducting surveillance of T and C. Incidental role – not involved for commercial gain – participation emerged from coincidental presence.
Cummings NSW CCA [347] 4.12.2007	Supply	19.28g	VG	6y NPP 4y	AA 5y 5m NPP 4y (To correct statutory ratio only)	Drug offences	Female - Supplied to others from home.
Vera NSW CCA [33] 25.2.2008	Supply	19.5g	VG	2y NPP 6m	Crown AD		Deemed supply – heavy drug user – jury not satisfied all drug found at house for personal use only Significant evidence of rehabilitation
Huynh (29) NSW CCA [216] 22.9.2008	Supply 9 x Proceeds of Crime offences	29.42g	PG	Drug offences: 4y NPP 2y 6m Total: 4y NPP 3y 3m	AD	Significant – including drug offences	Drugs found in house with supply paraphernalia – supplied to friends and self use – below mid-range – proceeds of crime offences related to $3.5m over 4 months – very favourable factual findings Vitenamese
Stanton (42) NSW CCA [326] 17.12.2008	Supply methylamphet 2 x Knowingly take part in supply methylamphet Knowingly take part in supply ecstasy Sched: 2 x supply	38.58g M 2.27g E	PG	3y 9m NPP 2y 3m	AA 2y 9m NPP 1y 10m	Long record	Part of drug distribution – facilitator – Sold to undercover police operatives over I month – well above street dealing Drug addict – aboriginal – care of three children – ill mother - parity
Reid (34) NSW CCA [37] 25.2.2009	Supply ecstasy Supply methylamphet Supply Ice Knowingly take part in supply Base Sched: 5 offences	1 tabs (4.99g) 3.31g 0.1-2g 0.08g	PG	2y 1m NPP 1y 4m	AD	Nil	Found in car weighing drugs – intended to supply to passenger – other drugs fond in car – admitted supplying ice – lower end of network Drug addition – depression – good prospects of rehabilitation – voluntary disclosures – assistance – remorse
Scott (29) NSW CCA [103] 25.5.2010	Supply s.166 Offences: 3 minor drug offences	27.1g	VG	2y 6m NPP 1y 10m (concurrent sentences)	AA 20m NPP 15m	Nil relevant	Deemed supply 27.1g – found in freezer in home – drug user – low level seriousness – low purity Good prospects of rehabilitation